Choosing the right trailer is key to shipping efficiently and saving money. This guide breaks down the differences between reefer trucks and dry vans, helping you understand their uses, costs, and advantages. Learn which option works best for your cargo, whether it’s perishable goods or standard freight, so you can make smarter, budget-friendly shipping decisions with YK Freight.
What is a Dry Van?
A dry van is one of the most common types of trailers in the trucking industry. It’s a fully enclosed, unrefrigerated trailer designed to transport non-perishable goods safely over short or long distances. Dry vans are versatile, reliable, and ideal for a wide range of cargo, from household items to packaged goods.
Typical Dimensions
Most dry vans are 13.5 feet high, 8.5 feet wide, and 48–53 feet long. These dimensions make them suitable for carrying palletized, boxed, or loose freight while remaining within legal highway limits. Their large size allows carriers to maximize each load efficiently, which is especially important for budget-conscious shippers looking to get the most value from every trip.
Features
Dry vans come with several features that make loading and transport easier:
- Roll-up doors for quick access to cargo.
- Loading ramps on some models to facilitate easier movement of goods.
- Aerodynamic skirts to improve fuel efficiency on long hauls.
Full Truckload and LTL Shipments
Dry vans are flexible in handling both full truckloads (FTL) and less-than-truckload (LTL) shipments. FTL shipments are ideal for larger cargo, such as furniture or machinery, while LTL shipments allow multiple smaller consignments to share the trailer, saving money on transport costs.
What Are the Advantages of Using a Dry Van?
Dry vans are popular for a reason—they offer a versatile, reliable, and cost-effective solution for transporting non-perishable goods. Whether you’re shipping locally or across the country, dry vans can handle a wide range of cargo while keeping it safe from damage.
Versatility for Local and Long-Distance Hauls
Dry vans are suitable for both short and long trips, making them perfect for budget-conscious shippers. You can use a dry van to move goods across town or across multiple states without needing different trailers for each route. This flexibility saves time and avoids extra costs associated with switching trailers.
Ability to Carry a Wide Variety of Non-Perishable Goods
From furniture and electronics to packaged foods, clothing, and household items, dry vans can handle almost any dry cargo that doesn’t need temperature control. Their size and design allow you to transport full truckloads (FTL) or less-than-truckload (LTL) shipments, helping you maximize efficiency and reduce shipping costs.
Convenience of Drop-and-Hook Method
Many dry vans allow for drop-and-hook operations, which means you can drop off a loaded trailer at the destination and immediately hook up a new trailer to continue your route. This method saves time, reduces waiting at docks, and increases the number of shipments you can handle, directly boosting profits.
Security and Protection from Theft and Weather
Being fully enclosed, dry vans protect cargo from rain, snow, hail, and theft. Whether you’re transporting electronics, boxes of clothing, or furniture, your goods remain secure throughout the journey. This feature is especially valuable for shippers who want to avoid unexpected losses or damage.
What Are the Disadvantages of Using a Dry Van?
While dry vans are versatile and cost-effective, they do have some drawbacks that shippers should be aware of, especially when transporting sensitive or moisture-prone cargo.
Wood Floors Can Be Prone to Moisture Damage
Most dry vans have wooden floors, which are durable but susceptible to moisture damage. Rain, snow, or even humidity can seep into the wood, causing warping or rot over time. This may lead to occasional repairs, which can add to maintenance costs if you’re shipping frequently.
Condensation Can Affect Cargo
Condensation can form inside the trailer, particularly during temperature changes or bad weather. While this doesn’t usually affect all types of cargo, items like electronics, cardboard boxes, or sensitive materials can be damaged if moisture is not properly managed.
What is a Reefer?
A reefer trailer, also known as a refrigerated trailer, is designed to transport perishable goods and temperature-sensitive products safely across short or long distances. Unlike dry vans, reefers have built-in temperature control systems that keep cargo at a specific temperature, protecting it from spoilage or damage.
Typical Dimensions
Reefers are similar in size to dry vans, usually 13.5 feet high, 8.5 feet wide, and 48–55 feet long. However, due to insulation and temperature-control panels, the interior cargo space is slightly smaller, which is important to consider when loading larger shipments.
Core Components
Reefers rely on several key components to maintain a controlled environment:
- HVAC system to regulate air circulation and maintain temperature.
- Evaporator and condenser to manage heat exchange inside the trailer.
- Compressor and reefer engine to power the cooling system.
- Metal flooring that resists moisture and expands less than wood, which is critical for preventing damage to refrigerated goods.
What Are the Advantages of Using a Reefer?
Reefer trailers offer several advantages that make them a valuable choice for carriers, especially when shipping perishable or temperature-sensitive goods.
Protection from Theft and Weather
Like dry vans, reefers are fully enclosed, which protects cargo from rain, snow, hail, and theft. The added insulation and refrigeration system also ensure that products stay at the correct temperature, which is essential for goods like frozen foods or pharmaceuticals.
High Demand for Refrigerated Goods
Perishable products are always in demand, from food and beverages to medical supplies. This high demand allows carriers to charge higher rates for reefer shipments, making them potentially more profitable than standard dry van loads.
Flexibility to Carry Dry or Temperature-Sensitive Products
While reefers are designed for refrigerated goods, they can also transport dry products if needed. This versatility allows carriers to pick up a wider variety of shipments, reducing empty return trips (deadhead miles) and improving overall efficiency.
Reduced Deadhead Miles
By being able to carry both refrigerated and dry freight, reefers give carriers more opportunities to fill their trailers on both outgoing and return trips. This helps save money on fuel and increases the number of profitable shipments per route.
What Are the Disadvantages of Using a Reefer?
While reefer trailers offer versatility and high demand, they also come with certain drawbacks that shippers need to consider, especially those on a tight budget.
More Complex Maintenance and Temperature Monitoring
Reefers are more complex than dry vans, requiring constant monitoring of temperature to ensure cargo safety. Any malfunction in the HVAC system, compressor, or other components can lead to spoiled goods, which means extra responsibility and attention for the carrier.
Regular Cleaning for Food Safety Compliance
When transporting food or pharmaceuticals, reefers must meet strict cleanliness standards. This means trailers need frequent cleaning and sanitizing to comply with regulations like the Food Safety Modernization Act (FSMA), adding both time and maintenance costs.
Pre-Cooling Takes Extra Time
Before loading perishable cargo, reefer trailers must often be pre-cooled to the desired temperature. This extra preparation makes reefers less convenient for drop-and-hook operations compared to dry vans, potentially slowing down delivery schedules.
Higher Costs Due to Equipment and Fuel Consumption
Reefers are more expensive upfront because of the refrigeration equipment and insulation. The refrigeration system also increases fuel consumption, adding to operating costs, which is an important factor for budget-conscious shippers.
Noise and Slower Loading/Unloading at Docks
The reefer motor can be loud during operation, and most docks require extra care when loading or unloading temperature-sensitive cargo. This can lead to longer turnaround times compared to dry vans.
Can You Use a Reefer as a Dry Van?
The short answer is yes—reefer trailers can carry dry freight—but there are a few important considerations to keep in mind.
Slight Reductions in Load Capacity and Interior Space
Because reefer trailers are heavily insulated and equipped with refrigeration equipment, using one for dry goods slightly reduces the cargo capacity. On average, you may lose about 500–1,000 pounds of carrying capacity and roughly three inches of interior space on the sides and top. While these reductions are small, they can affect how much you can load, particularly for bulkier items.
Different Stabilization Methods and Careful Loading
Dry cargo must be loaded and stabilized differently in a reefer. For example, while temperature-sensitive products rely on airflow and insulated walls, dry goods need load bars, airbags, or other securing methods to prevent shifting during transit. Improper loading could damage the cargo or affect balance, so extra care is essential.
Reefer vs Dry Van Rates: Which is More Cost-Effective?
When deciding between a dry van and a reefer, cost is a major factor, especially for budget-conscious shippers. Understanding the differences in upfront and long-term expenses can help you make the best choice for your shipments.
Upfront Costs
Dry vans are generally cheaper to purchase and operate because they lack refrigeration systems, insulation, and other specialized components. Reefers, on the other hand, require a higher initial investment due to the refrigeration engine, HVAC system, and metal flooring. This makes dry vans the more economical option if your cargo doesn’t require temperature control.
Long-Term Profitability of Reefers
Despite the higher upfront costs, reefers can be more profitable over time. Temperature-sensitive goods like frozen foods, pharmaceuticals, and other perishables are always in demand, allowing carriers to charge higher rates for reefer shipments. Less competition for reefer loads also means it’s easier to find cargo, reducing empty trips and increasing overall revenue.
Considerations for Budget-Conscious Shippers
Shippers need to weigh short-term savings versus long-term earning potential. If you only transport dry, non-perishable goods, a dry van keeps upfront costs low and is simple to operate. But if you occasionally haul perishable items or want flexibility to take advantage of higher-paying loads, investing in a reefer may pay off in the long run.
Which Should You Choose: Reefer or Dry Van?
Choosing between a reefer and a dry van depends on your specific shipping needs, cargo type, and budget. Both trailers have unique advantages and disadvantages, so understanding the differences is essential for making an informed decision.
Key Differences
- Temperature Control: Reefers provide refrigeration and insulation, keeping perishable goods safe. Dry vans do not, making them suitable only for non-perishable cargo.
- Versatility: Reefers can haul both dry and temperature-sensitive goods, offering more flexibility. Dry vans are limited to dry, non-perishable freight.
- Costs and Maintenance: Dry vans are cheaper to purchase and maintain, while reefers require more investment and upkeep, including monitoring temperature, pre-cooling, and cleaning.
Factors to Consider
When choosing a trailer, think about:
- Cargo Type: Do you transport perishable or fragile goods, or mostly standard non-perishables?
- Shipping Frequency: Are you running regular shipments where flexibility is important, or occasional deliveries that don’t require refrigeration?
- Budget: Are you prioritizing low upfront costs, or can you invest in a trailer that may generate higher rates and long-term profit?
Example for Budget Shippers
A small business shipping furniture and boxed goods can save money using a dry van with YK Freight, avoiding the extra costs of refrigeration they don’t need. On the other hand, if the same business wants to expand into perishable foods or pharmaceuticals, investing in a reefer trailer with YK Freight ensures safe transport, opens access to higher-paying loads, and reduces empty backhauls.
Ultimately, the right choice depends on your specific shipping needs. By analyzing cargo type, delivery frequency, and budget, shippers can maximize efficiency and cost-effectiveness while safely transporting their goods.
ASK YOUR QUESTIONS